Kilowatt Almanac

Would a heat pump cost less than your furnace?

Start from the fuel you burned last winter. See what a heat pump would cost to deliver the same heat, using your state's gas and electricity prices.

How the home is heated now
therms
From last winter's bills, November to March. If you don't know it, the starting figure is the same heat as EIA's average gas-heated home (48 thousand cubic feet a winter).
$ per therm
%
COP
The average over a whole winter, not the best-case rating. To convert a heat pump HSPF2 rating, divide it by 3.41: an HSPF2 of 8.1 is a seasonal COP of about 2.4.
¢ per kWh
Filled in from your state's average residential price (August 2026, EIA). Your bill shows your own rate; type it here for an exact answer.

A heat pump giving the same heat this winter would cost

for November to March

Your current system
Heat pump electricity
Heat delivered to the house
Heat pump breaks even at a COP of

At these prices a heat pump would save about a winter.

At these prices a heat pump would cost about more a winter than what you have now.

Where your price sits among the states

U.S. 18.16¢
Nevada 12.72¢Hawaii 47.18¢

How the comparison is worked out

The calculator starts from the heat your home actually needs, measured by the fuel you already burn. It takes that fuel, removes what your furnace or boiler loses up the flue, and asks how much electricity a heat pump would need to deliver the same heat.

Heat delivered = fuel used × energy per unit × furnace efficiency
Heat pump electricity = heat delivered ÷ 3,412 Btu per kWh ÷ COP

Energy content used: natural gas 100,000 Btu per therm, propane 91,452 Btu per gallon, heating oil 138,500 Btu per gallon, electricity 3,412 Btu per kWh.

Example at U.S. averages. A home burning 48 thousand cubic feet of gas (498 therms) in a 95% furnace gets 47.3 million Btu of heat. At the 2025 average gas price that costs $736.32. A heat pump with a seasonal COP of 2.5 would need 5,544 kWh, which costs $1,007 at 18.16¢. At these national averages gas is cheaper to run. The heat pump would have to average a COP of 3.4 to match it.

Switch the fuel to propane or heating oil and the answer flips. At current EIA prices, a heat pump beats both by a wide margin in most states.

What this does not include

  • Installation cost and rebates. This is running cost only. Equipment, labor and incentives change the payback, not the winter bill.
  • Fixed gas charges. If a heat pump lets you close your gas account entirely, you also stop paying the monthly gas customer charge. Add twelve months of it to the savings.
  • Cooling. A heat pump is also an air conditioner. If it replaces an old AC unit, summer bills can drop too.
  • Very cold snaps. Many systems switch to backup resistance heat in the coldest hours. That lowers the seasonal COP, which is why the field asks for a seasonal figure, not a rating at 47°F.

Cost of a million Btu of heat in 2026

At U.S. average prices, here is what the same amount of delivered heat costs from each option.

Heat sourcePrice usedPer million Btu delivered
Natural gas furnace, 95%$1.48 per therm$15.57
Heat pump, seasonal COP 2.518.16¢ per kWh$21.29
Propane furnace, 95%$2.826 per gallon$32.53
Heating oil boiler, 85%$5.26 per gallon$44.68
Electric baseboard or space heater18.16¢ per kWh$53.22

Questions

What COP should I use?

For a modern air-source heat pump in a mixed climate, a seasonal COP of about 2.5 to 3 is a reasonable starting point. Ground-source systems often average 3 to 4. In very cold regions, or with a unit sized too small, it can fall below 2.5. If you have the HSPF2 rating, divide it by 3.41.

Why does an installer's estimate look better than this?

Estimates often use a heat pump's rated COP at mild temperatures, or compare against an older, less efficient furnace. Try the installer's numbers here: enter their seasonal COP and your real furnace efficiency.

Where do the gas and propane prices come from?

Natural gas uses your state's 2025 average residential price from the EIA, converted at 10.37 therms per thousand cubic feet. Propane uses EIA's latest weekly U.S. residential price, and heating oil uses EIA's forecast average for this winter. You can type your own price over any of them.

Sources

Prices last updated November 17, 2026 from EIA data. Reviewed by the Kilowatt Almanac editor. Found a mistake? Tell us and we will fix it.